Nutty Butter is a container of orange peanut butter with a yellow label with her face on it. She has a green stick of celery and a lavender butter knife in her as well as an orange peanut on the side.
Her variant is a darker orange container of brown peanut butter with a white label with her face on it. She has a dark green stick of celery, a magenta butter knife and a brown peanut.
She is also included in the Vending Machine Storage Tin. This variant of her is a dark pink container of brown peanut butter with a yellow label. This variant has a yellow stick of celery, a light pink butter knife and a brown peanut.
There is also an exclusive variant of her from the Mystery Edition #3 pack. This variant features her as a peach container of yellow peanut butter with a white label on it. She has a yellow stick of celery, a pink butter knife, and a yellow peanut. She is lightly coated with glitter.
- The Shopkins Collector's Tool shows Nutty Butter's Vending Machine Storage Tin variant as a blue jar with a pink label. However, she is actually a magenta jar with a yellow label.
- It also says that her Vending Machine Storage Tin variant is from Season Five.
- Her eyes on her figures are placed higher than where they are portrayed on her catalog art.