Mary Wishes is a cupcake with a pink holder and chocolate icing that fades into pink, with a white candle that has a red flame. She is also holding a white present and a white card.
Her variant is a cupcake with a purple holder and light blue frosting that fades into pink. She has a blue candle with an orange flame and is holding a blue present and a blue card.
She has 2 Easter Egg variants. The first is a cupcake with a yellow holder, plain pink icing, and a pink candle to match her card and present. The second is a cupcake with a purple holder, white present, white card, yellow candle, and yellow and orange ombré frosting.
- Her name is a pun on "Merry wishes" or "Many wishes" and the name "Mary".